What Social Security is Looking For?
Unlike physical impairments, where it’s easy to prove a disability using x-rays or blood tests, mental impairments are largely based on the subjective complaints an individual makes to their mental health doctors. Therefore, an individual alleging a disabling mental condition must be seeing a mental health professional. One of the first things Social Security looks for when evaluating a claim for benefits for depression is treatment records. A lack of treatment implies that the person is able to manage the depression by him or herself, and therefore the condition is not severe enough to prevent them from working. Missed appointments or gaps in the records tend to show that the individual either does not need help or is contributing to their impairment by not complying with proper treatment.
In the records themselves, Social Security looks for symptoms. For Major Depression, there must be consistent records stating that 4 of the following severe symptoms have persisted despite treatment: anhedonia or pervasive loss of interest in almost all activities, appetite disturbance with change in weight, sleep disturbance, psychomotor agitation or retardation, decreased energy, feelings of guilt or worthlessness, difficulty concentrating or thinking, thoughts of suicide, or hallucinations, delusions, or paranoid thinking.
Once it is determined that at least 4 of the above symptoms exist despite ongoing treatment, Social Security checks to see if the symptoms have lasted or will likely last at least 12 months.
Next, Social Security evaluates the impact these symptoms have on an individual’s ability to function. Though the symptoms may exist, they may be mild and therefore a person can potentially work despite the symptoms being present. However, if the symptoms are very severe, they would probably prevent the person from working at any job.
At this step, Social Security needs the help of a mental health expert to help determine the severity of the symptoms. A treating psychologist or psychiatrist is in the best position to provide an opinion as to the level of impairment their patient’s symptoms are causing. Specifically, Social Security is interested on how much an individual’s depressive symptoms interfere with their ability to perform activities of daily living, how much interference there is with normal social functioning, how much the depression effects a person’s ability to concentrate, persist or keep a working pace, and how many episodes of decompensation the depression has caused. If a treating doctor does not provide information on the severity of the claimant’s depression, one of Social Security’s medical examiners will provide such an opinion based on either an examination or a review of the records.
Presenting a Strong Case
Of course the most important part of proving a case for disability to be able to present treatment records. Not being able to afford treatment is not an excuse because there are free clinics and county mental health facilities that can assist those in dire financial shape. All claimants should have records to prove that they in fact do have a diagnosis of major depression.
It is important to discuss the symptoms of your depression with your doctor so that these symptoms can be written in your record.
To prove that the symptoms severely impact your ability to work, a statement from your doctor is necessary. Because a person’s treating doctor is most familiar with their case, that doctor’s opinion is usually given the most weight and therefore it’s vital to proving the case for disability. The opinion of the treating doctor can be in the form of a short narrative or can be provided as part of the doctor’s progress notes.
Social Security evaluators also look for in-patient stays at mental health facilities to determine if the individual shows signs of decompensation or an inability to function outside a highly structured living arrangement.
Another tool used to determine the severity of a claimant’s depression is their GAF, or Global Assessment of Functioning score. The GAF tells how well an individual functions in their life. Scores of less than 50 tend to show that an individual is below the normal level social functioning and has a significant impairment in this area.
Social Security red flags, which are often used as the basis for denials, are drug use and non-compliance. Claimants who use drugs or alcohol when they have depression are often denied because the effects of the substance cannot be distinguished from the effects of the mental impairment. Therefore, it is viewed as though the claimant is contributing to their disability. It is advantageous to have sustained sobriety from drugs and alcohol for at least 6 months before applying for disability benefits due to depression. Also, claimants who fail to take their medications are considered to be contributing to their impairment. Such cases are often denied because it is presumed that with proper medical management, the depression would resolve.
Therefore, to strengthen a case for disability based on depression, the following should be part of the record: consistent visits with the mental health doctor which state the symptoms of depression, compliance with medications, sobriety from street drugs and alcohol, and a supportive statement from the treating doctor which explains the level of impairment the depression causes in the individual.
No comments:
Post a Comment